Thus, for example, a gun in a museum cabinet has a different meaning to a gun being pointed at you by a nervous burglar. Using selections from historians, criminologists, social scientists, public health specialists, and jurists, dr. Whether youve loved the book or not, if you give your honest and detailed thoughts then people will find new books that are right for them. The book is ambitious and covers many topics but it does so at a price, the lack of depth. More than any other advanced industrial democracy, the united states is besieged by firearms violence. Jan 10, 20 so, as we move into this season of change on gun policy, lets take a moment to better frame the debate. Opinion the debate that goes nowhere the new york times. Opinion why not regulate guns as seriously as toys. It is a call to break away from established ideas, approaches, and practices, and to boldly tread a new path in quest of understanding what may very well be the greatest mystery of all.
Reframing the debate is a collection of original essays exploring alternative perspectives on ufos and how we might more usefully study the phenomenon in the 21 st century. The collection begins with a kind of backandforth approach between experiencerstrue believers and skeptics, prefacing entries by more nuanced theorists, who look at the ufo phenomena from perspectives that are refreshingly different from the mainstream extraterrestrial hypothesis ethabductionnuts and bolts approaches. No topic is more polarizing than guns and gun control. What aristotle, lincoln, and homer simpson can teach us a. Roods book should be required reading for any citizen wanting to engage in a. Over the course of its history, the nation has witnessed the murders of beloved public figures. Argument framing when you are arguing for or against something, you may frame your argument by giving broad detail about other contributory factors before making your major point. In 1963, lee harvey oswald bought a boltaction riflean italian militarysurplus weaponfor nineteen dollars and ninetyfive cents by ordering it. Amy mitchell, acting director, pew research centers project for excellence in journalism.
One important reframing strategy involves making the issue less abstract and more personal. Oct 06, 2017 ten lies distort the gun control debate. University of michigan press, 2009, accessed 18 may. The gun debate is written in an admirably neutral tone. Mass shootings, mental illness, and gun control wiley online. These books will make you think differently about the gun. A generally conservative legislator, who somewhat unexpectedly found himself supporting samesex marriage, called it putting a face on the. In part, obama is trying to reframe the gun discussion not as a. Oct 08, 2015 here are three books that bring intellectual rigor and analysis to both sides of the american gun control debate. What everyone needs to know delves into the issues that americans. The book brings together some of the most progressive and iconoclastic thinkers in the field for an incisive deconstruction of current popular ideas.
When americans with opposing views on guns sit down to talk. In the aftermath of the shooting at marjory stoneman douglas high school, americans across the country of differing views expressed their thoughts, prayers, and opinions concerning the shooting. Reframing the debate, is a mixed affair, with some entries being of greater interest than others. Oct 04, 2017 the desire for safety is basic and universal. Susan morrelsamuels, ma, mph, miyvpc managing director most of us are familiar with some of the steps that have led to greater safety on our highways. Reframing the debate by robbie graham white crow books. Other readers will always be interested in your opinion of the books youve read. How republicans successfully reframe the gun debate.
The guncontrol debate, explained in 5 questions the. Debate books showing 150 of 469 the benefits of being an octopus hardcover by. As a result, rates of death from automobile crashes in. To help the gun situation people that want to buy guns should have to go through a thorough background check. President obama reframes the gun debate the new yorker. In summary, the book succeeds in covering many topics of interest in the gun debate. In this series, you will learn what framing is, why it matters, and how it profoundly influences our understanding of social challenges and how we think and talk about potential. The current economic and political climate places ever greater pressure on public organizations to deliver services in a costefficient way. Reframing the gun violence debate in terms of public health jean phillip shamiframing is critical. The term gun control as it is used in the united states refers to any action taken by the federal government or by state or local governments to regulate, through legislation, the sale, purchase, safety, and use of handguns and other types of firearms by individual citizens the political and social debate over the question of how much gun control is. There is no connection between mass gun ownership and gun deaths. Blow wants to reframe the debate on the right to bear arms following the latest mass shooting, in newtown connecticut.
Every gun is legally manufactured and often legally imported into the united states and then is legally sold to a gun shop. But its poisoned from the getgo by a tower of babel predicament. Sociologist jeffrey langstraat describes the use of this strategy in the debate in the massachusetts state house. When you are arguing for or against something, you may frame your argument by giving broad detail about other contributory factors before making your major point.
While it is true that some guns are stolen from gun shops or illegally sold from gun shops, the manufacturing of a gun and the original sale of a gun to the gun retailer are legal. Reframing the debate, a new edited volume of fourteen original essays exploring alternative perspectives on ufos and how we might more thoughtfully study the phenomenon in the 21st century, with a foreword by dr. The gun debate isnt about what you think usa today. Sep 19, 20 as more details emerge of navy yard shooters troubled past, lawmakers appear to be reframing debate over gun violence around better treatment for mental health. Francisco reframing the gun debate statehouse live. Jan 12, 20 re reframing the gun debate by jeremy r. Air bags, seat belts, strict penalties for drunk driving, graduated drivers licensing, and better road design are examples of successful highway safety strategies. Public service efficiency reframing the debate taylor. Parkland activists hope their proposal sets the tone for debate in both political parties in the leadup to 2020. Reframing the constitutional debate over gun control. Picture this is a multipart series presented in partnership with the communications network, the frameworks institute, and leading organizations working on todays most urgent and seemingly intractable social issues.
Apr 02, 20 reframing the gun debate to reduce gun violence tsm worldwide llc. So, as we move into this season of change on gun policy, lets take a moment to better frame the debate. Although the federal government and many states have at one time or another had on their books statutes forbidding the distribution of. Indeed, this reframing of the issue shifts the burden to proponents. Jan 31, 20 its the biggest, fiercest debate taking place across america. From a gun culture that took root early in american history to the mass shootings that repeatedly bring the public discussion of gun control to a fever pitch, the topic has preoccupied citizens, public officials, and special interest groups for decades. To enact policies that reduce gun violence in the united states, advocates are flipping the script to make the conversation about saving lives rather than taking away americans guns. The history of guns in america was never onesided time. Columbias gun laws, the nra, appearing as an amicus curiae, con.
The gun control debate spikes in attention and shifts in public opinion. Oct 19, 2000 columbine and other highly publicized shootings have kept americas centuryold gun debate in the forefront of public attention. Three in ten american adults say they own a gun and 67% say protection is a major. Summarizing results from hundreds of studies, the book makes a hugely positive contribution toward. Understanding the origins of american gun culture can help reframe todays gun debate. Focused on the costs of service delivery, governments across the world have introduced a series of business like practices from performance management to publicprivate partnership in the belief that these will increase the efficiency of their. To enact policies that reduce gun violence in the united states, advocates are flipping the script to make the. Apr 19, 2012 the modern gun debate began with a shooting. The questionandanswer format worked well and provides readers with a handy reference. Gun violence in america was a uc berkeley event series that engaged the nations foremost experts on gun violence in reframing public debate, laying the groundwork for new research and advocacy, and ultimately lessening gun violence in the united states. As more details emerge of navy yard shooters troubled past, lawmakers appear to be reframing debate over gun violence around better treatment for mental health.
Reframing the debate is a cold, hard, slap in the face for ufology, delivered with love. Mar 17, 2008 reframing the constitutional debate over gun control. Nov 23, 2015 on gun control, for instance, liberals are persuaded by stats like, no other developed country in the world has nearly the same rate of gun violence as does america. And when, time and again, congress thwarts gun reforms that are supported. Here are some excellent books to read if you want to better understand the debate. Mark jurkowitz, associate director, pew research centers project for excellence in journalism 202 4193650 1615 l st, n. Parkland survivors gun control plan aims to reframe the debate on. Policymakers clearly need help seeking new ways to curb armed violence in america. The orlando shooting illustrates, once again, how thorny the issue of gun rights has become.
Ann braden goodreads author shelved 7 times as debate avg rating 4. The disagreement is over whether guns actually make one safer. Jun 17, 2016 guncontrol supporters are often disadvantaged in the debate because many dont know very much about firearms or gun violence. The what everyone needs to know subtitle means the gun debate is part of a book series published by oxford university press that covers a range of topics.
The benefits of being an octopus by ann braden, thank you for arguing. The change in gun control to gun safety is just to make people more aware of using a gun and all the responsibilities that come with it. Unlike the stupid hysterics over net neutrality, tax policy, or regulatory reform, the gun debate really is at its heart about life and death. Cook and goss, public policy professors at duke university, provide. And how does it characterize americas gun debate, particularly debates over the. I describe the book as a cold, hard, slap in the face for ufology, delivered with love. In this series, you will learn what framing is, why it matters, and how it profoundly influences our understanding of social challenges and how we think and talk about. Columbine and other highly publicized shootings have kept americas centuryold gun debate in the forefront of public attention. Opinion reframing the gun debate the new york times. Nisbet provides an indepth analysis of the central issues involved in our debate over guns. The new york times botches americas history with the gun.
1606 1052 503 924 425 1366 76 304 901 1309 1375 671 393 611 1162 1353 494 799 1500 1621 1658 1581 742 1584 729 536 515 1178 1295 173 93 817 440 880 143